Replacement Grips vs. Overgrips: Which Tennis Grip is Best for You?

Updated at: 04/06/2025

The perfect tennis grip is crucial for control, comfort, and ultimately, your game's success. But with a dizzying array of options available, choosing between replacing your entire grip or simply adding an overgrip can feel overwhelming. Do you opt for the clean slate of a full replacement, offering a potentially longer-lasting solution and a chance to experiment with different grip sizes and materials? Or do you favor the quick, cost-effective fix of an overgrip, allowing for frequent changes and customized feel? This seemingly simple decision can significantly impact your performance. The choice hinges on several factors, from your playing style and sweat level to your budget and maintenance preferences.

This article will delve into the pros and cons of both replacement grips and overgrips, providing a comprehensive comparison to help you make the informed decision that best suits your needs. Follow along as we guide you through a step-by-step process to determine which grip—replacement or overgrip—is the optimal choice for your tennis game.

Preparation and Safety Guidelines

Tools Needed

Safety Guidelines

Always ensure your grip is securely fastened to avoid slippage during play, which could lead to injury.
If you experience any discomfort or pain while using a new grip, stop immediately and consult a professional. Improper grip size or type can cause wrist, hand, or elbow problems.
Regularly check your grip for wear and tear. Worn grips lose tackiness and can compromise your game and potentially cause injury.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Introduction to Grips
- These are the base grips directly applied to your racket handle. They have adhesive backing for easy application.
- These are added on top of the replacement grip, providing extra cushioning and tackiness. They're usually thinner than replacement grips.
Introduction to Grips
Reasons to Skip the Overgrip
- Reasons to ONLY use a replacement grip (without an overgrip):
- Feel more racket vibration and feedback for better ball control.
- Avoid extra thickness and weight.
- Overgrips wear out faster, saving you money.
Reasons to Skip the Overgrip
- Feel the bevels of your racket grip for enhanced feel.
- Personal preference for the feel of a replacement grip.
Reasons to Skip the Overgrip
Reasons to Use an Overgrip
- Reasons to use an OVERGRIP (in addition to a replacement grip):
- Added cushioning, tackiness, and roughness for better grip.
- Slightly increase grip size.
- Overgrips are generally cheaper.
Reasons to Use an Overgrip
- Aesthetics – wider color selection.
- Avoid feeling the bevels for a more rounded grip.
- Personal preference for the feel of an overgrip.
Reasons to Use an Overgrip

Tips

The presenter's personal preference is using only a replacement grip, prioritizing feel and feedback for topspin and slice shots.
An overgrip might be considered for added cushioning if experiencing elbow pain.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Using Overgrips Too Tightly

Reason: Wrapping overgrips too tightly restricts blood flow to your hands, leading to discomfort, cramping, and reduced feel for the ball.

Solution: Wrap overgrips with a comfortable, slightly loose tension, leaving a small gap between the wraps.

2. Ignoring Grip Size and Shape

Reason: Using a grip that's too large or small, or doesn't match your playing style and hand size, can lead to blisters, poor control, and fatigue.

Solution: Experiment with different grip sizes and shapes to find one that feels comfortable and allows for optimal control and power.

FAQs

How often should I replace my grips, whether replacement or overgrip?

Overgrips should be replaced when they become worn, slippery, or lose their tackiness – typically every few weeks to a month depending on your sweat level and playing frequency. Replacement grips usually last much longer, 3-6 months or even longer with proper care, but should be replaced if they become excessively worn or damaged.