This review dives into the Set & Match board game, comparing its Standard and Maxi editions. Both versions offer a unique, flicking-based simulation of tennis, challenging players to strategically aim balls across a game board to score points. The core gameplay remains consistent across both editions, involving rally points, net rules, and bonus points for skillful shots like drop shots and cross-court winners. However, significant differences in size, components, and overall playing experience set the two apart.The Standard Set provides a compact and budget-friendly introduction to the game, featuring a smaller board, felt-aided gameplay, and cylindrical scoring markers. The Maxi Set, on the other hand, boasts a significantly larger playing area, smoother wooden balls eliminating the need for felt, and a sophisticated neoprene carrying bag. We'll explore the specific components of each edition, detail the rules and scoring systems, and ultimately help you determine which version best suits your needs and budget, whether you prioritize a premium playing experience or a more affordable entry point.
Pros And Cons
- Larger size
- Larger balls
- Smoother gameplay
- Comes with a neoprene bag
- Uses triangle scorers instead of cylinders
- Rules are only two or three pages
- Does not include felt
- Nice quality
- Includes multilingual rule booklet
- Simple gameplay
- Plays like real tennis
- Rule booklet is only two pages
- Felt may not be necessary for gameplay
Read more: TenniScore Review: 3 Versatile Ways to Use This Tennis Scorekeeper
Unboxing and Components
The Set & Match board game comes in a surprisingly slim box. Inside, you'll find a rulebook in multiple languages (English, French, German, Spanish, Italian). The rules themselves are concise, fitting on just two pages.
The game includes a high-quality game board, a set of small balls, and felt pieces to improve the gameplay surface. Extra balls and felt pieces are included, adding to the value.
Wooden scoring markers and a rally point marker are also provided for tracking the score. The components are well-made and aesthetically pleasing.
Gameplay Overview
Set & Match is a flicking game simulating tennis. Players take turns flicking balls across the board, aiming for designated squares. Successful shots continue the rally, while misses result in points for the opponent.
The game board features numbered squares that affect the rally score. Landing on a numbered square advances the rally point marker. The first player to reach a predetermined score wins the game.
Net rules are also incorporated, adding a layer of strategy and excitement. If the ball hits the net, the position of a black dot on the ball determines whether the serve is replayed or considered a fault.
Advanced Rules and Scoring
The game includes bonus points for drop shots and cross-court shots. Landing a drop shot in certain squares awards extra points. Similarly, successful cross-court shots earn additional points.
The 'ace' feature adds another layer of skill and reward, giving an automatic point for specific successful serves. The black dot aids in determining the accuracy of shots and scoring.
The rules concerning ball placement and scoring are clearly explained and enhance the strategic gameplay.
Standard vs. Maxi Set Comparison
The Maxi Set is significantly larger than the Standard Set, roughly double the size. The larger size provides a more spacious playing area.
The Maxi Set's balls are larger and made of wood, offering smoother gameplay. The smoother surface removes the need for felt, a feature of the Standard Set.
The scoring system also differs between versions, with the Maxi Set using triangular markers compared to the cylindrical markers in the Standard Set. The Maxi Set also comes in a high-quality neoprene bag.
Conclusion and Recommendation
Both the Standard and Maxi Set versions of Set & Match offer enjoyable gameplay, capturing the essence of tennis in a unique way. The concise rulebooks make learning the game straightforward for both versions.
The Maxi Set offers a superior playing experience due to its larger size, smoother wooden balls, and high-quality neoprene bag. However, the Standard Set remains a budget-friendly option.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your budget and preferences. If you prefer a more substantial and smoother playing experience, the Maxi Set is worth the investment. If you want a less expensive game that provides similar gameplay, the Standard Set is a good option.