This review compares two variations of Penn Championship Extra Duty tennis balls: optic orange and yellow. The comparison focuses on differences observed in packaging, appearance, and on-court performance. One set of orange balls was purchased in Canada, revealing packaging differences from US versions, including a notable warranty promising replacement if the customer is dissatisfied. A side-by-side test involving a ball machine and three players was conducted to assess performance discrepancies between the orange and yellow balls.The testing revealed subtle differences. While the amount of felt remaining on both ball types after twelve hits was similar, a noticeable discrepancy in distance was observed, with the orange balls appearing to travel a shorter distance. However, this difference wasn't significant enough to drastically impact gameplay. Ultimately, the review explores whether these observed differences – in packaging, appearance, and distance – significantly impact the overall performance and value of these popular tennis balls.
Read more: Top 5 Dunlop Tennis Balls: A Buyer's Guide
Packaging and Initial Observations
My review focuses on comparing two variations of Penn Championship Extra Duty tennis balls: optic orange and yellow. The optic orange balls were purchased in Canada from Canadian Tire, a general store with a large sporting goods section. The packaging immediately revealed differences; the Canadian-bought balls featured French text on the packaging, unlike their US counterparts.
A key distinction was the inclusion of a warranty section on the Canadian packaging. This warranty promises replacement if any dissatisfaction arises upon opening the can. This warranty shows a commitment to customer satisfaction.
Visually inspecting the balls themselves, I noticed a difference in cosmetic flaws. The yellow balls appeared to have more noticeable blemishes compared to the smoother, visually superior orange ones. This difference in appearance was consistent across multiple cans.
On-Court Performance Comparison
To assess performance, my wife and brother joined me in a test. We hit each type of ball twelve times using a ball machine, allowing for a fair comparison. Surprisingly, the amount of felt remaining on both types of balls seemed equivalent after the test.
However, my wife observed that the orange balls seemed to travel a shorter distance than the yellow balls under the same conditions. She noted that the orange balls landed noticeably sooner than the yellow balls which is intriguing.
This discrepancy in distance could be attributed to several factors, including variations in the manufacturing process. Further investigation using more controlled testing scenarios might be needed to reach a more definitive conclusion. More testing could verify whether this was a consistent issue.
Overall Conclusion and Verdict
Despite the differences in appearance, packaging, and the slight distance observation, my overall conclusion is that the Penn Championship Extra Duty tennis balls, in both optic orange and yellow, offer similar performance. The variance in distance is not a significant difference and there is no decisive evidence that it is a consistent problem.
The Canadian packaging's warranty is a nice extra touch and the cosmetic differences are mostly subjective. The choice between the two colors may come down to personal preference, with consideration for the warranty.
While a slight difference in distance was noted, it wasn't drastic enough to significantly impact gameplay. Both balls offer solid performance, and I would recommend either color.